Skip to content
Powering the UK's most efficient NHS Right to Choose providers
← Blog

No data, no funding: 3 changes the Fonagy review wants from Right to Choose providers

The Fonagy review wants Right to Choose providers to report referrals, wait times and outcomes separately for NHS-funded and private patients as a condition of funding. That would show NHS-funded patients waiting 7 to 8 times longer, and wait times counted from the first referral.

Mohammad Abbas · Co-Founder & CTO, Cerebric
Dr. Moniem Abdu · Co-Founder & CEO, Cerebric
· Updated · 5 min read
Cerebric LogoCerebric
NHS
In this article
  1. Key takeaways
  2. 1. Data split by payer
  3. 2. NHS-funded vs private wait times
  4. 3. Wait times from first referral
  5. About the authors
  6. Frequently asked questions
  7. Citations

The Fonagy review (the independent review into mental health conditions, ADHD and autism, published by the Department of Health and Social Care on 9 October 2026) found that commissioners fund much of the independent sector's work but see little data about it. On provider estimates, independent providers delivered more than half of NHS-funded ADHD assessments and more than a third of autism assessments in 2025/26, around 90% of it through Right to Choose (p306). The review says commissioners "often cannot see what they are paying for" (p18).

Key takeaways#

  1. Referrals, wait times and outcomes should be reported separately for NHS-funded and private patients, as a condition of funding.
  2. Reporting by payer would show NHS-funded patients waiting 7 to 8 times longer than private patients at the same providers.
  3. Wait times should count from a patient's first referral, not restart each time they are re-referred.

1. Referrals, wait times and outcomes should be reported separately for NHS-funded and private patients, as a condition of funding#

The government's 9 October response did not mention this, but it said ICBs must improve their oversight of the services they commission. Some reporting is already required: under the 2026/27 payment guidance, every provider of NHS-funded assessments, Right to Choose included, must send data to MHSDS or CSDS.

Few providers send data today. Right to Choose is a legal right rather than a contract, so providers generally do not have to send the routine data commissioners can require under a contract, and only around 10 of about 120 ADHD providers submitted data (p329).

Only around 10 of about 120 ADHD providers submitted dataEach dot stands for one of the approximately 120 ADHD providers the Fonagy review counted, and the light blue dots stand for the around 10 that submitted data. Right to Choose is a legal right rather than a contract, so providers generally do not have to send the routine data commissioners can require under a contract.Submitted dataDid not submit dataAround 10 of about 120 ADHD providers submitted data.The grid is illustrative. The review gives approximate counts, does not date them and does not say which data set the providers submitted to. The dot positions do not stand for specific providers.

The review makes three proposals that would change what you report:

  • Data would become a condition of funding and accreditation. Recommendation 5 says all providers, including Right to Choose, should submit activity, quality and outcomes data, with NHS-funded and privately funded referrals, wait times and outcomes reported separately (p445).
  • MHSDS would cover functioning, participation and outcomes at every provider, including Right to Choose (p430).
  • Outcomes would be reported by ethnicity, deprivation and other characteristics. Separately, Recommendation 8 asks for a minimum dataset that records intellectual disability, functional communication and adaptive functioning (p447).

Together, these point to eight measures a provider should be able to produce for any period, split by Right to Choose, other NHS contracts and private patients:

  • referrals received and accepted;
  • wait times from first referral to first assessment, and to the report being sent;
  • assessments completed, missed appointments and late cancellations;
  • outcomes: diagnosis made, not made, or referred on;
  • which conditions were assessed, with the clinical reason for any combined ADHD and autism assessment;
  • post-diagnostic contacts;
  • functioning or outcome measures, where you record them;
  • ethnicity, and an area deprivation score from the postcode.

The measure on combined assessments matters because the review found that current tariffs may encourage them, since they pay more whatever the clinical need (p329). It wants separate assessments, carried out in a planned sequence with shared clinical oversight, where more than one is needed (p444).

2. Reporting by payer would show NHS-funded patients waiting 7 to 8 times longer than private patients at the same providers#

At the same providers, NHS-funded patients waited a mean of 151 days for an ADHD assessment and 170 days for an autism assessment, compared with 21.5 days for privately funded patients (pp306–307). The 7 to 8 times ratio is our own calculation, because the review gives no sample size or period.

Mean wait times for NHS-funded patients are 7 to 8 times longer than for private patients at the same providersMean wait time for an assessment, in days, at the same independent providers, as reported in the Fonagy review, an independent report to the government. The review gives one figure for privately funded patients, 21.5 days, which it does not split by ADHD and autism.Privately funded patientsNHS-funded patientsADHD assessmentNHS-funded patients wait about 7 times longerPrivately funded, both conditions (single figure): mean wait time 21.5 days, about three weeks.ADHD, NHS-funded: mean wait time 151 days, about five months, about 7 times longer than privately funded patients.Autism assessmentNHS-funded patients wait about 8 times longerPrivately funded, both conditions (single figure): mean wait time 21.5 days, about three weeks.Autism, NHS-funded: mean wait time 170 days, about five and a half months, about 8 times longer than privately funded patients.All figures are means. The ratios are our own calculation, and the review gives no sample size or period for these figures, so treat them as a rough guide.

Today nobody outside the clinic sees this gap. Where NHS-funded and private patients share clinicians, the way the clinic decides who is seen first should be written down.

3. Wait times should count from a patient's first referral, not restart each time they are re-referred#

National figures treat each referral as a separate episode, so the clock restarts after discharge, redirection or re-referral. Re-referral is common, not a rare case. Across ten children's mental health services, almost 1 in 3 referrals was rejected, redirected or closed without the child being seen, and around 3 in 10 of those children were referred again within a year (p302). Autism presentations had the highest re-referral rate, at just over half (p300). In one city, the median time to diagnosis was 18.2 months counted from the latest referral, but 38.9 months once all of a child's referrals were linked (Box 14.3, p306). A combined autism and ADHD pathway there cut these to 9.3 months, down from 18.2 months, and 16.0 months, down from 38.9 months.

Median time to diagnosis more than doubles when counted from a child's first referralMedian time to diagnosis, in months, for the same children in one city, from a regional analysis done for the Fonagy review. National figures restart the clock at each new referral; linking all of a child's referrals raises the median from 18.2 months to 38.9 months.Median time to diagnosis, from the latest referral: 18.2 months.How national figures count: the clock restarts at each new referralMedian time to diagnosis, from the first referral: 38.9 months.The gap between the two counts is 20.7 months.Linking every referral for the same child

The review says linked data should make each person's whole journey visible to commissioners (p313). Wait times should therefore be recorded from the first referral a provider holds, not only from acceptance. When a patient switches from NHS-funded to private care, the NHS referral should be closed and a linked private one opened, because overwriting the payer makes a long NHS wait look like a short private one.

NHS England will also consult on national prices for ADHD and autism services, intended from April 2027. Our overview of the Fonagy review covers that and the review's other proposals for providers, and the government's full response is due in a Mental Health Strategy "in the coming months".

About the authors

Mohammad Abbas headshot

Mohammad Abbas

Co-Founder & CTO, Cerebric

Mohammad Abbas is the co-founder and CTO of Cerebric. He built health AI systems at IBM before leading engineering at Cerebric, where he focuses on secure systems for regulated healthcare settings. Seeing a family member go through a neurodevelopmental assessment shaped his commitment to making that process work better for clinicians and patients.

Profile and all articles
Dr. Moniem Abdu headshot

Dr. Moniem Abdu

Founder & CEO, Cerebric

Dr. Moniem combines medical training with experience at McKinsey & Company's AI arm, QuantumBlack. His NHS experience revealed how poorly designed systems disrupt clinical focus, driving him to build clinician-first tools that reduce cognitive load and protect clinical judgement.

Profile and all articles

Frequently asked questions

What data does the Fonagy review want from Right to Choose providers?

Recommendation 5 says all providers, including Right to Choose providers, should submit consistent activity, quality and outcomes data as a condition of funding and accreditation, with NHS-funded and privately funded referrals, wait times and outcomes reported separately.

Is the Right to Choose data condition now a requirement?

No. It is a recommendation, and the government's 9 October 2026 response did not mention it. NHS England's 2026/27 payment guidance already requires providers of NHS-funded assessments, including Right to Choose providers, to send data to MHSDS or CSDS.

How long did NHS-funded patients wait compared with private patients at the same providers?

NHS-funded patients waited a mean of 151 days for an ADHD assessment and 170 days for an autism assessment, compared with 21.5 days for privately funded patients. On our calculation, that means NHS-funded patients waited 7 to 8 times longer. The review gives no sample size or period for these figures.

Will Right to Choose prices change?

The government has committed to a consultation. NHS England will consult on a national set of prices for NHS-funded ADHD and autism services, covering assessment, post-diagnostic support and follow-ups, and intends to introduce new payment arrangements from April 2027. The review found that tariffs for apparently equivalent assessments differ by around fourfold between ICBs.

Citations(6)
  1. DHSC: Independent review into mental health conditions, ADHD and autism: final report
  2. DHSC: Government pledges earlier support to tackle mental health crises (9 October 2026)
  3. CQC: CQC to regulate autism and ADHD diagnostic assessments
  4. IHPN: Building better neurodevelopmental services
  5. NHS England: 2026/27 NHS Payment Scheme, ADHD and autism payment guidance
  6. NHS England Digital: Introduction to the Mental Health Services Data Set (MHSDS)

Get new articles and product updates by email

Guides for ADHD and autism assessment services and what's new in Cerebric.

Unsubscribe at any time. See our privacy policy.

More in the Fonagy review series

Related articles